Sagamore Hill and Montauk Point on separate days
Choose between the Oyster Bay history site and the lighthouse at Long Island’s eastern end.
Decide which part of Long Island the day is about. Sagamore Hill gives you a historic house and grounds visit. Montauk Point Lighthouse is a separate outing much farther east. Treat the trip between them as a commitment in its own right.
Area highlights map

Sagamore Hill is point 1 and Montauk Point Lighthouse is point 2. Use the map to orient your visit and check the venue’s directions for the public entrance.
Plan the two stops
Plan the Sagamore Hill visit around the experience you want
The National Park Service lists Sagamore Hill in Oyster Bay and says tours of the Roosevelt Home are by advance reservation only (National Park Service Sagamore Hill visitor information, checked November 20, 2026). Check the National Park Service’s current information for visiting the grounds and booking a house tour. Give the property enough time and use the exact site address when deciding how to arrive.
Check the lighthouse before heading east
New York State Parks places Montauk Point on the eastern tip of Long Island’s South Shore (New York State Parks Montauk Point visitor information, checked November 20, 2026). For the lighthouse itself, use the Montauk Historical Society’s visitor information, which the state park page links to. If climbing or entering the lighthouse matters, check current access separately from seeing the surrounding area.
Visit choices

These stops are far apart. Plan them within separate parts of your Long Island visit.
- Oyster Bay area to Sagamore Hill. Check grounds and house visit arrangements.
- Eastern Long Island to Montauk Point Lighthouse. Check lighthouse and visitor access.
Example visit
Use the shorter window for whichever site is closer to your base. Give the other its own day unless you have already allowed enough time for both approaches.
Common questions
Which stop makes the better anchor?
Choose Sagamore Hill if the house visit is what you most want. Look up tour availability before arranging the rest of your day. Use Montauk for a day where the coast is the focus, and check that the parts of the lighthouse visit you want are available.
More on Wayfinder
Plan the separate Sagamore Hill house experience